IP Archives of Cytology and Histopathology Research

Print ISSN: 2581-5725

Online ISSN: 2456-9267

CODEN : IACHCL

IP Archives of Cytology and Histopathology Research (ACHR) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2016 and is published under the Khyati Education and Research Foundation (KERF), is registered as a non-profit society (under the society registration act, 1860), Government of India with the vision of various accredited vocational courses in healthcare, education, paramedical, yoga, publication, teaching and research activity, with the aim of faster and better dissemination of knowledge, we will be publishing the article more...

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 422

PDF Downloaded: 343


Get Permission Yaggati, Shashikala P, Rajashree K, and Kamaradgi: Histomorphological changes of skin in electrocution deaths - A study in a tertiary care hospital


Introduction

Electrocution is one of the major public health concerns with high morbidity and mortality. Electrocution mainly occurs due to poor maintenance of electric equipment, misuse, and carelessness and lack of knowledge of electrical hazards coupled with lack of safety measures.1, 2, 3 Death due to electrocution is considered as an unnatural death caused by the passage of electric current either high or low voltage into the body.4, 5 Maximum number of electrocution deaths (EDs) occurs with low voltage i.e., between 110-380V in which voltage range of home and industry exists.6 While high voltage (>600) EDs mainly occur at work and are mostly accidental.7

Skin is the most frequently involved tissue in electrocution injuries, but electrocution changes can also be seen in heart, muscles, intra-abdominal organs, bone, neural tissue, and orbit.8, 9, 10 Electric marks on skin, which is specific and diagnostic of contact with electricity, is one of the strong indications of death by electrocution.11 The electric marks show a significant variety of gross morphology.12 However, reduced cutaneous resistance and low voltage of current are two factors that facilitate the traceless passing of current through skin.13 When the characteristic findings of electrocution on the body are absent, histopathological study of the skin can be helpful to ascertain the cause of electrocution by excluding the other possible cause of death and by circumstantial evidence collected from the incidence site.

Several recent studies have affirmed that histological examination could be an important aspect in diagnosis of electrocution.11, 12, 14 Currently, the diagnosis of death from electrical injury quite often is based on histopathological findings and electric contact marks.12 Therefore, there is a possibility to make a firm diagnosis of suspicious lesions in dead bodies. 15 Hence, the study aims to analyse cutaneous gross and microscopic changes of skin in cases of EDs and its association with respect to its electrical voltage in cases of EDs to establish the cause of death in medicolegal autopsy.

Materials and Methods

The retrospective study was done at the department of pathology at a tertiary care hospital, between January 2017 to December 2019. Medical records of patients who expired due to electrocution in the study period were reviewed. The study comprised of all EDs having specific electric mark on the skin. Deaths from any other cause, thermal and lightening electrocution deaths were excluded from the study. The Ethical committee clearance was obtained from the institutional ethical committee before the study initiation.

Following post-mortem, autopsies of all non-lightening ED at department of Forensic Medicine, specimen of skin comprising of suspected entry and exit wound along with normal skin as control sent to Pathology department were examined. A detailed history of the victim like age, sex, occupation, manner of death, type of voltage, and place of death were obtained from the medical records. The skin samples were preserved in 10% neutral buffered formalin and were examined for gross changes. The sections were then subjected to routine histopathological tissue processing and stained with Haematoxylin and Eosin. On microscopy, the histopathological changes in skin observed in both entry and exit wound were recorded in a proforma and analysed. Each case comprised of an entry wound, exit wound, and control skin. All 17 cases had suspected entry wounds, only 12/17 cases had exit wounds and 17 controls were received from corresponding normal skin.

Statistical analysis

R v4.1.1 was used to analyse the data. Categorical variables are given in the form of frequency table and the dependency was analysed using Chi-square test. Continuous variables are given in Mean ± SD/Median (Min, Max) form. P ≤ 0.05 indicates significance.

Results

The study included 46 skin samples from 17 non-lightening ED whose age ranges from 7 years to 65 years with mean age of 34.53 ± 15.54years and male to female ratio being 7.5:1.Most of the ED occurred at workplace (70.5%) during their job and electric line man commonly succumbed to electrocution (29.4%). Most of the job-related deaths occurred due to high voltage (58.8%) which is the voltage supplied for major industries and overhead transmission wires and domestic causes were of low voltage. All the EDs were accidental (100%) in nature (Table 1).

Upper extremity (51.7%) and lower extremity (31.0%) were the most common areas of electrical injuries. Entry wounds predominantly involved upper extremity and exit wound the lower extremities. All 5 cases which did not have exit wound probably died in wet location where skin lowers the electrical resistance. The gross changes at both sites of wound appear to be almost similar with slight variation in exit marks. Most common gross abnormality in entry wound was ulcer/crater (Figure 1) over the skin (82.3%) followed by blister/bulla formation (70.5%). Splits in the skin/laceration (75%) was the most common observation in the exit wounds (Figure 2). The microscopic examination of skin showed the epidermis, dermis with underlying subcutaneous tissue. The histopathological changes in both entry and exit wound are quite similar with slight difference. Both entry and exit wound showed dermoepidermal separation (clefting) as the most common finding i.e., 88% and 75% respectively followed by epidermal necrosis (82, 66%) and nuclear streaming (76%, 50%; Table 2).

The nuclei of epidermal cells at the site of electrical burn showed stretching and narrowing of the contour to produce a palisade like appearance which are pyknotic, darkly stained on Hematoxylin and Eosin. This peculiar distortion of nuclei specially at basal layer of epidermis is called nuclear streaming which is pathognomonic for passage of electric current. Dermoepidermal separation was observed in most of the cases. (Figure 3). There was microvesicle formation at multiple foci of epidermis in both entry and exit wounds (47%, 17% respectively) i.e, separation of intraepidermal cells. Coagulative necrosis of dermal collagen with loss of adnexal structures appeared faintly basophilic on H and E stain (homogenisation of dermis) was noted predominantly in entry wound (5 cases, 29%) and not in exit wound. Epidermal necrosis in entry wounds is significantly associated with high voltage electrocution (P=0.04),(Figure 4) While there is no significant association of other microscopic features with respect to its voltage (Table 3) Table 4 shows no significant association of any microscopic features with respect to its voltage in exit wounds.

Table 1

Baseline characteristics

Variables

N (%)

Age (years)

0–10

1 (5.88%)

11–20

2 (11.76%)

21–30

3 (17.65%)

31–40

5 (29.41%)

41–50

3 (17.65%)

51–60

2 (11.76%)

61–70

1 (5.88%)

Gender

Female

2 (11.76%)

Male

15 (88.24%)

Nature of work

Lineman

5 (29.4%)

Field work – farm fence

3 (17.6%)

Domestic

4 (23.5%)

Playing

1 (5.8%)

Other job

4 (23.5%)

Voltage

High voltage

8 (47.06%)

Low voltage

4 (23.53%)

High/low voltage

4 (23.53%)

Nature of death

Accidental

17 (100%)

Suicidal or homicidal deaths

0 (0.00%)

Table 2

Affected body parts, gross appearance, microscopic appearance of the skin in entry and exit wounds

Entry wound

Exit wound

Affected body parts

Upper extremity

12 (70.5%)

03 (25.0%)

Lower extremity

02 (11.8%)

07 (58.3%)

Chest and abdomen

02 (11.8%)

01 (8.3%)

Head and neck

01 (5.9%)

01 (8.3%)

Gross appearance

Ulcer/crater on the skin

14 (82.3%)

Split skin/ Laceration

-

09 (75%)

Blister formation

12 (70.5%)

05 (41.6%)

Skin discolouration

08 (47.0%)

02 (16.6%)

No abnormality

02 (11.7%)

01 (8.3%)

Microscopic appearance

Dermoepidermal separation (clefting)

15 (88%)

09 (75%)

Epidermal necrosis (coagulative necrosis)

14 (82%)

08 (66%)

Nuclear streaming

13 (76%)

06 (50%)

Microvescicle formation

08 (47%)

02 (17%)

Homogenization in dermis

05 (29%)

-

Hemorrhage and congestion

04 (24%)

04 (33%)

Inflammatory response

01 (6%)

-

Normal skin

01 (6%)

01 (8%)

Table 3

Association ofHistopathological findings in entry wound with voltage

Microscopic features

Subcategory

High Voltage

Low Voltage

p-value

Dermoepidermal separation (clefting)

No

0

2 (33.33%)

0.12MC

Yes

11 (100%)

4 (66.67%)

Epidermal necrosis (coagulative necrosis)

No

0

3 (50%)

0.04MC*

Yes

11 (100%)

3 (50%)

Nuclear streaming

No

3 (27.27%)

2 (33.33%)

1.00MC

Yes

8 (72.73%)

4 (66.67%)

Microvescicle formation

No

5 (45.45%)

4 (66.67%)

0.62MC

Yes

6 (54.55%)

2 (33.33%)

Homogenization in dermis

No

6 (54.55%)

6 (100%)

0.12MC

Yes

5 (45.45%)

(0%)

Hemorrhage and congestion

No

8 (72.73%)

5 (83.33%)

1.00MC

Yes

3 (27.27%)

1 (16.67%)

Inflammatory response

No

11 (100%)

5 (83.33%)

0.37MC

Yes

(0%)

1 (16.67%)

[i] Chi square test with Monte Carlo simulation, * indicates statistical significance.

Table 4

Association ofHistopathological findings in exit wound with voltage

Microscopic features

Subcategory

High Voltage

Low Voltage

p-value

Dermoepidermal separation

No

3 (27.27%)

5 (83.33%)

0.06MC

Yes

8 (72.73%)

1 (16.67%)

Nuclear streaming

No

7 (63.64%)

4 (66.67%)

1.00MC

Yes

4 (36.36%)

2 (33.33%)

Epidermal necrosis

No

5 (45.45%)

4 (66.67%)

0.62MC

Yes

6 (54.55%)

2 (33.33%)

Microvescicle formation

No

7 (63.64%)

6 (100%)

0.25MC

Yes

4 (36.36%)

(0%)

Hemorrhage and congestion

No

9 (81.82%)

6 (100%)

0.52MC

Yes

2 (18.18%)

(0%)

[i] MC – Chi square test with Monte Carlo simulation.

Figure 1

Entry wound on palm

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f550b557-8a02-429d-8cf2-83147eb6f6f2image1.png
Figure 2

Exit wound on Sole

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f550b557-8a02-429d-8cf2-83147eb6f6f2image2.png
Figure 3

Dermoepidermal separation with nuclear streaming (H & E Stain, X40)

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f550b557-8a02-429d-8cf2-83147eb6f6f2image3.png
Figure 4

Epidermal necrosis (H & E Stain, X40)

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f550b557-8a02-429d-8cf2-83147eb6f6f2image4.png

Discussion

The medicolegal investigation in EDs needs greater and mindful detailing as it is an important cause of negative autopsy. In cases with no electric contact marks, uncertain history, and anecdotal evidence coupled with histopathological examination of skin can be of great help in arriving at the diagnosis of ED. The present study showed that histological signs both at the site of entry and exit wounds with respect to its voltage facilitated the diagnosis of suspicious lesions during autopsy.

Electrocution results in an unnatural death. With the widespread use of electricity, the incidence of fatal and non-fatal electric injuries increased. In our study, all of them occurred accidentally; 1, 3, 16, 8 however, homicidal, and suicidal deaths were stated in few reports.1, 16 Maximum number of EDs were in the age group of 21 to 50 years (65%) which was similarly observed in other studies. Consistent to our study, males are the predominant victims as they are frequently exposed to the electrical menace.1, 3, 16, 17

Previous studies reported majority of deaths due to low voltage electricity, which is commonly used in households and at workplaces in India.16, 8, 13 Majority (74%) of investigated deaths occurred during leisure time, while the rest occurred at workplace.1, 18 The present study showed predominantly occupation related deaths (70%) due to high voltage current while the remaining occurred at domestic places (29%) which partly correlated with other studies.1, 2, 19 Direct contact with the power line might be the probable reason behind high rate of EDs with high-voltage electrical currents.7

Although, the skin offers maximum resistance to the electric current, water still lowers the resistance of the skin and electric current density. 20 Hence, no electrical marks can be found when death occurs in or near moist and water places. In the present study,5/17 cases did not have exit wound probably due to similar reason. The most frequent site of entry wound was upper extremity in (70.5%).7, 21 Obvious exit wound was commonly seen on the sole of the feet or other parts of lower extremities (58.3%), which is in accordance with other studies. 1, 21

Electric marks caused by electric injuries show varied gross morphology. Grossly electric marks are round to oval with a shallow crater. The crater floor is lined by pale flattened skin. In some marks there will be skin infringement within or near margin of crater, resembling that of a broken blister22 which is similarly seen in the present study suggesting dermoepidermal separation. Walia et al., study reported epidermis and dermis were involved in most (70%) of the cases while metallisation or inflammatory response of the tissues, blister formation, was not present in any of the cases.15Sometimes, the skin mark is distinctly pale, but there may be hyperemia of skin immediately beyond it. We noticed skin discolouration, most of them pale area in 6 cases and zone of redness in other 2 cases. Therefore, microscopic findings like epidermal and dermal separation, coagulative necrosis in both entry and exit wounds helps in arriving at the diagnosis of electrocution death. Dermoepidermal separation is formed by space between epidermis and dermis due to the gas liberated from heat.23 Coagulative necrosis of the underlying dermis and subcutaneous tissue occurs due to denaturation of the protein which gives a bluish colour in haematoxylin and eosin stain.24 Further, in our study, epidermal necrosis in entry wounds was mostly due to high voltage electrocution (P=0.04). However, proper internal and external examination can help in ruling out the other causes. The incidence of dermoepidermal separation, coagulative necrosis of epithelium and nuclear streaming were comparable with other studies.1, 4, 5 Other similar studies also showed dermo-epidermal separation in 100%,4 90.9%, 25 73.3-83.3% cases; necrosis in 90.9% and 66.6%4 cases. Few studies reported that streaming of nuclei in the basal epithelial layers is the other predominantly seen histopathological change in the peripheral areas of electric injuries (96%), but in the present study the basal epithelial layer in most of the cases was extensively destroyed or lost due to electrical injury.11, 17, 21 Other studies described bulla formation in 22.5% cases in epidermis14 and 5% cases in dermis,14 vacuolisation in 12.5% cases,14 micro-blistering in 81.8% cases. 25 Death is mainly due to ventricular fibrillation and respiratory paralysis.

The study revealed that histological changes are supportive in differentiating EDs from other types of injuries to facilitate proper diagnosis during autopsy. The presence of epidermal necrosis, a characteristic microscopical feature, suggesting electrocution produced by high voltage electrical current. This indicates forensic surgeons can rely entirely on the histopathological findings of organs to conclude the cause of EDs.

Similar cutaneous changes may be found in cases of flame burns and abrasions since thermal energy or hyperthermia plays an important role in causation of these lesions and may mislead the diagnosis. Subepidermal separation also occur in flame burns or abrasions however intraepidermal separation is most frequently seen in electrical lesions. So intraepidermal separation alone or a combination of intraepidermal and subepidermal separation in a lesion is most likely to be caused by electricity. Epidermal nuclear elongations are prominent in electrical lesions while they are mild in abrasions. Dark nuclear staining is marked and homogenization of dermis can be deep in abrasions. Coagulative necrosis of both epidermis and dermis is absent in abrasions but less frequently present in flame burns. 11, 15

Previous reports stated that nuclear elongation and streaming are caused by the polarization effect of the current. 2 But it has recently been postulated that these nuclear changes are caused by expansion resulting from heat since they are also seen in flame burn lesions. The nuclear changes are significantly seen in higher proportion of electric injuries and they are seen in variably low proportions in flame burns and abrasions. 11

Conclusion

Electric contact mark is diagnostic criteria for electrocution in cases of suspected sudden death. Further, histopathological changes in skin give the supportive evidence in determining the cause of death especially in case of negative autopsy as these changes are found consistently in most of the fatal electrocution. The important microscopic features of electrocution are dermoepidermal separation, coagulative necrosis, and nuclear streaming. EDs in many situations are accidental, and they can be prevented by taking proper precautions, regular inspection, and maintenance by authorized persons. Further, there should be ongoing laws and security crusade for decreasing the mishaps from electrocution at domestic and industrial places. Instructions should be followed, and regular inspection and maintenance should be done by the authorised person.

Acknowledgment

None.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.

Source of Funding

None.

References

1 

S Kumar A K Verma U S Singh Electrocution-related mortality in northern India - A 5-year retrospective studyEgypt J Forensic Sci2014411610.1016/j.ejfs.2013.07.001

2 

B Gupta R A Mehta M Trangadia Profile of deaths due to electrocution: A retrospective studyJ Indian Acad Forensic Med2012341135

3 

R Wick J D Gilbert E Simpson R W Byard Fatal electrocution in adults--a 30-year studyMed Sci Law20064621667210.1258/rsmmsl.46.2.166

4 

B Viswakanth P Shruthi Low Voltage Electrocution Deaths and Histopathological Findings: One-Year Prospective Autopsy Study. undefined. Published online 2015. Accessed November 24, 2021. 2021https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Low-Voltage-Electrocution-Deaths-and-Findings%3A-Viswakanth-Shruthi/014e565e1b6e746393ca65c69ab3f1cc12d2706e

5 

A G Pathak N A Devraj K M Chaudhari R K Gadhari Death Due to Fatal Accidental Electrocution: A case report2015411336Int J Res Med

6 

Z Peng C Shikui Study on electrocution death by low-voltageForensic Sci Int1995762115910.1016/0379-0738(95)01804-2

7 

B Massey M Sait W Johnson M Ripple D Fowler L Li Deaths due to electrocution: An evaluation of death scene investigations and autopsy findingsJ Forensic Sci Med2018441798310.4103/jfsm.jfsm_57_18

8 

B Karger O Süggeler B Brinkmann Electrocution--autopsy study with emphasis on “electrical petechiaeForensic Sci Int20021263210310.1016/s0379-0738(02)00061-0

9 

R Blumenthal A retrospective descriptive study of electrocution deaths in GautengBurns20013568889410.1016/j.burns.2009.01.009

10 

A S Gajbhiye M M Meshram R S Gajaralwar A P Kathod The management of electrical burnIndian J Surg20137542788310.1007/s12262-012-0476-x

11 

C Sangita G Garima Y Jayanthi A Arneet K Neelkamal Histological indicators of cutaneous lesions caused by electrocution, flame burn and impact abrasionMed Sci Law20185842162110.1177/0025802418776116

12 

RHM Al-Hadithi NGH Al-Khateeb MAJ Abdullah Forensic Histopathological Approach to ElectrocutionJ Fac Med200850310.32007/jfacmedbagdad.5031257

13 

K Chandru Study of electrical injuries in fatal cases at Victoria hospitalIndian J Forensic Med Toxicol200342358

14 

D Walia R Kaur J Gargi D Singh A Aggarwal Histopathological Changes in Skin after Electric Current Injury: An Autopsy StudyJ Clin Diagn Res2018121HC01410.7860/JCDR/2018/32173.11065

15 

İ Üzün E Akyıldız M A İnanıcı Histopathological differentiation of skin lesions caused by electrocution, flame burns and abrasionForensic Sci Int200817821576110.7860/JCDR/2018/32173.11065

16 

F Marak B Kumar G Study of electrocution deaths in Puducherry2017

17 

R N Patil J Tijare W Raut Histopathological Examination of Skin in Electrocution Deaths: One Year Autopsy StudyIndian J Forensic Community Med20214425560

18 

S Caues C Herbst S Wadee A retrospective review of fatal electrocution cases at Tygerberg Forensic Pathology Services, Cape Town, South Africa, over the 5-year period 1S Afr Med J2008108121042510.7196/SAMJ.2018.v108i12.13131

19 

M Shrigiriwar Electrocution: A six-year study of electrical fatalitiesJ India Acad Forensic Med2007292503

20 

R M Fish L A Geddes Conduction of Electrical Current to and Through the Human Body: A ReviewEplasty20099e44

21 

S Giri A Waghmode N K Tumram Study of different facets of electrocution deaths: a 5-year reviewEgypt J Forensic Sci20199110.1186/s41935-018-0103-5

22 

MBBS Medicine (Humanity First): Injury due to heat and electricity. Accessed November 26, 2021https://www.medicinembbs.com/2011/08/injury-due-to-heat-and-electricity.html

23 

R Sidbury 103 - Newborn Skin Development: Structure and FunctionAvery’s Dis Newborn2018146810.1016/B978-0-323-40139-5.00103-0Elsevier

24 

A Astier The Different Types of Necrosis and Their Histological Identifications. Andréas Astier. Accessed November 26, 2021https://www.andreasastier.com/blog/the-different-types-of-necrosis-and-their-histological-identifications

25 

B Guntheti U Singh S Khaja Diagnosis of electric injuries: Histopathological examinationJ Indian Acad Forensic Med201436213741



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

Article type

Original Article


Article page

47-53


Authors Details

Neetha Yaggati, Shashikala P, Rajashree K, Pravinkumar N Kamaradgi


Article History

Received : 28-01-2022

Accepted : 01-02-2022


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files